In this episode, Grampa Simpson and Mr. Burns, the wealthiest man in Springfield, are the last two surviving members of a tontine. The man who lives the longest gets sole possession of a trove of paintings their WWII unit plundered decades earlier. Mr. Burns hires an assassin to take out Grampa Simpson and hijinks ensue.
Why am I telling you about a 29-year-old cartoon?
That’s because among the items classified as alternative assets in Trump’s executive order is the line, “Lifetime income investment strategies including longevity risk-sharing pools.”
I’ve been making calls over the last week looking into what exactly that could mean, and experts interpreted the “longevity risk-sharing pools” portion as effectively describing tontines.
Well, what’s a tontine?
I’m glad you asked. Tontines are investment pools where participants share longevity risks by distributing the assets of those who die as "mortality credits" to surviving participants.
Essentially, they are investment vehicles in which "members commit funds irrevocably," with the resources and income claims of those who die distributed among those who survive, according to a 2020 report from the Brookings Institution, a Washington-based think tank.
Beyond that, tontines can be structured in any number of ways, from closed-end pools with increasing monthly distributions and the last man or woman standing "winning the lottery," to open-ended pools with mortality credits adjusted to account for the different life expectancies of surviving members and monthly payouts maintained at a constant level, my recently retired colleague Doug Appell wrote in a 2021 story.
These days, people in a tontine wouldn’t have to worry about a Mr. Burns-like character planning their early demise, according to that Brookings report. “The mechanisms involved are not very different from how group annuities operate, and members of modern tontines would be mutually anonymous in any case,” the report said.
The experts with whom I’ve spoken in recent days all said they were surprised to see the lifetime income sentence included under an alternative assets umbrella.
“It’s definitely not like the other items,” Larry Pollack, principal at LIP Consulting and a tontine proponent, told me. “A tontine pool, there's no particular investment that's required for that. It's really more a methodology that allows you to generate lifetime income without insured products.”
Pollack over the years has written opinion pieces (including in P&I) espousing the benefits of modern tontines, which he argues would generate higher lifetime income than insured annuities.
“All else equal, in forgoing the guarantees provided by insurance contracts, tontines should provide higher lifetime income on average through the reduction of expenses,” Pollack wrote.
Tontines were popular in the U.S. in the late 1800s and early 1900s but were effectively outlawed in response to corrupt insurance company management, according to Brookings.
Now, the White House is directing regulators to take a fresh look at the concept.
I asked a few attorneys what we may see from regulators, like the Department of Labor, on this issue and was told clear guidelines and potentially a safe harbor could be beneficial.
“The more regulatory uncertainty there is around something like lifetime income, the less likely employers are to do it,” Michael Kreps, a partner at Groom Law Group, told me. “And it's voluntary. They don't have to put lifetime income solutions in their plan. It's a fiduciary choice. They're taking on risk to do that.”
He added, “And so, the more the administration and Congress, all of them together, can put some protections in place, or give fiduciaries comfort, the more likely that those fiduciaries are to pick this up and run with it.”
I’ll have a story out later this week on this subject with additional comments from Kreps, Pollack and others.