But don’t be scared, the quiz is only one multiple choice question:
What’s something Australian that President Donald Trump said his administration is “very seriously” considering?
A. Asking recently crowned “Dancing with the Stars” champion Robert Irwin to perform at the White House.
B. Mailing every taxpayer an Outback Steakhouse Bloomin’ Onion*.
C. Making the U.S. retirement system more like Australia’s superannuation system.
D. Replacing the bald eagle with a kangaroo as the national symbol.
*Not actually Australian.
If you answered “C,” then congrats on acing the pop quiz. Your reward is that you get to read this newsletter each week.
If you answered anything else, see me after class. Your punishment is that you must read this newsletter each week.
OK, enough quiz talk. My colleague Sophie Baker and I have a story breaking down Trump’s comments that his administration is looking at ways to make the U.S. retirement system more like Australia’s.
For starters, here’s what Trump said last week at a White House event:
“There’s a certain Australian plan that people are liking that they’re talking about. There’s a plan where, not for children necessarily, but it’s for people, working people and we are looking at other things, different from this.”
A reporter asked Trump if he was referencing the Australian retirement program. He replied, “That’s what we’re talking about. We’re looking at it very seriously. It’s a good plan. It’s worked out very well.”
As you can see, there wasn’t much detail in Trump’s remarks, but we at P&I were curious to hear from some experts on the idea. To boil it down, an Australian-style model is unlikely to take off in the U.S., we were told.
“The most significant difference between the 401(k) system and the Australian system is the participation and contribution mandate in Australia for employers and employees,” said Josef Pilger, senior adviser, coach and author, and former global pension and retirement leader at EY.
Australia’s superannuation system requires employers to contribute 12% of employee pay to a portable account for the employee.
The 401(k) model is optional for employers and employees in the U.S., with an average contribution rate of 14.1% — 9.4% from employees and 4.7% from employers — according to data from Fidelity Investments. But 59 million American full-time workers lack access to employer-sponsored retirement savings plans and an additional 23.4 million gig economy workers also don’t have workplace retirement options, according to data from the Georgetown University Center for Retirement Initiatives.
Another major difference in the Australian and U.S. models is “the unique fiduciary duty concept in the U.S.,” Pilger said. That duty — which Pilger said “is the most significant barrier for innovation and progress in the U.S.” — sits with the employer as plan sponsor, which then selects the provider.
Going further on this point, in Australia, the provider of a super fund — like the A$406.3 billion ($263.6 billion) AustralianSuper, the largest in the country — takes on the fiduciary duty, which means better alignment of interests with savers, Pilger said. That includes providing them with financial advice, getting them to save more and transitioning into retirement or decumulation products, Pilger added.
There are other differences we get into in the story, but Bill Ryan, a partner and defined contribution team leader at NEPC, said that comparing the U.S. defined contribution system to the Australian system isn’t apples to apples.
“Most working Americans pay a contribution into Social Security, and I think we miss that Social Security and Australia are similar,” he said. “And then the DC market, which is also often conflated with the Australian market, is an add on.”
Ryan added, “Australia went to a sole defined contribution market without the other legs of the stool, where we have multiple legs of the stool,” including Social Security and defined benefit plans.
Separately, the Republican tax bill passed in July created Trump accounts, tax-deferred savings accounts for children, which could come into play here, Ryan noted.
Under the tax bill provision, each U.S. child born between 2025 and 2028 will get a Trump account seeded with $1,000 in federal funds.
“I think what I’m hearing from the president and the narrative is (that) the vehicle to get more like Australia is through the Trump accounts,” Ryan said, adding that the accounts are a good way to get more Americans investing for longer periods of their lives.
Again, there’s lots more info in our story, but that’s all for now. Class dismissed.