At this point, my brain is nearly defrosted, so let’s get back on track.
We’re very close to seeing the Department of Labor’s proposed rule on alternatives in 401(k) plans.
As you likely know, President Donald Trump issued an executive order in August directing the DOL to facilitate broader access to alternatives in 401(k) plans. He gave the DOL until early February to carry out the order, and in mid-January the DOL’s Employee Benefits Security Administration submitted a proposal to the White House Office of Management and Budget for review.
Shortly before the snow arrived, I spoke in Washington with John Toomey Jr., CEO of HarbourVest Partners, a private markets asset manager with $150 billion in assets under management, about a host of topics for a forthcoming story as part of P&I’s Face to Face series.
One of the main topics we discussed was alternatives in 401(k) plans.
At the moment, HarbourVest doesn’t have any business in the 401(k) plan space, but Toomey told me he expects that to change once new regulation is in place and called the market “a natural extension of why we exist.”
“We have the investment expertise and the structuring experience in the manager relationships to bring important diversification, so I think we're really well positioned,” Toomey told me.
“I think any time there's maybe a new format or a new channel, you of course want to invest and build specific capabilities,” he continued. “I would say we've already done that for things like open-ended (funds), for working with third-party distributors, we obviously already work with institutional investor plan sponsors on the defined benefit side. So from where I sit, all the pieces are in place, from HarbourVest’s standpoint, to bring our benefits to a whole new generation of savers.”
Toomey told me that HarbourVest is having conversations with target-date managers about offering products in 401(k) plans.
He also said he expects private market takeup among retirement savers to be slow until there’s more education on the benefits of asset diversification.
Though incorporating alternative assets in plan lineups is already legal under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, plan sponsors have historically steered clear for fear of litigation and other concerns like fees, liquidity and transparency.
Legal sources have said they expect the DOL to initiate a rule-making process and issue guidance aimed at providing sponsors with comfort in offering alternative assets to participants.
But not everyone is on board with the idea of opening up private markets to more retirement savers.
The Private Equity Stakeholder Project, a nonprofit advocacy group critical of the private equity industry, is out with data this week noting that some of the largest private equity-focused evergreen funds underperformed publicly listed stock indexes in 2025 despite charging higher fees.
Fifteen large private equity-focused evergreen funds highlighted by the Private Equity Stakeholder Project generated a median return of 11.2% last year, less than the S&P 500 index, which returned 17.4%, according to the group. The same 15 private equity evergreen funds generated a median annualized return of 11.2% over the last three years (2023-2025), compared to a 22.5% return in the S&P 500 index over the same period.
I asked a spokesperson from the Private Equity Stakeholder Project what they would like to see from the DOL on the subject.
“PESP opposes any safe harbor that would weaken fiduciary protections for retirement savers,” Matt Parr, the group’s communications director, said in an email Tuesday. “At a minimum, the Department of Labor should hold private equity to the same disclosure and transparency standards expected in public markets, including clear reporting on what funds are investing in, the fees and expenses retirement savers are paying, the amount of debt funds are using, and how these investments are actually performing compared with stocks.
"Given that many private equity funds have lagged public markets while charging much higher fees, and that public pension funds are pulling back from the asset class, the bar for including private equity in 401(k)s should be extremely high,” Parr added.